6 replies

lind26

Member since 24 Apr 2014

Total posts 230

Have you noticed in some publications when Reviewers rate an Air route they travel on, that the fare is paid by the hosting airline? How can that be Kosher?

Mal

Member since 14 Jun 2013

Total posts 109

I think that almost every publication which reviews a flight does so on an airfare paid by the airline simply because there's no way they could afford to pay for it themselves, unless it's a writer flying economy on their own holiday!

How can it be 'kosher'? Well you have to accept that the writer is going to write a fair report and not be swayed by the 'free' flight. I suppose some publications are more trustworthy than others. If they don't report honestly you won't trust them in future.

lind26

Member since 24 Apr 2014

Total posts 230

Yes but surely the Airline word up their staff in advance that someone is reviewing them that day?

eminere

Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer

Member since 25 Sep 2013

Total posts 371

Of course! Hence read the review with a (liberal) pinch of salt.

David

Member since 24 Oct 2010

Total posts 988

Not always, and even if they did, that can't change core elements such as the seat, comfort and arguably some meals. Journalists are trained to be impartial, and our first duty in reporting is to the readers who create the audience which advertisers want to reach. For us it's all about being fair, balanced and objective.

hutch

Member since 07 Oct 2012

Total posts 761

Which was my point yesterday with the whole travelex 'saga'. But at the end of the day, I've read enough reviews here to see that Ausbt mentions positives and negatives...

But let's take a reality check for 2 seconds... this is Ausbt, they are reviewing airlines and associated products. This is not investigative journalism. They are not exposing corruption or going to change the world. Whether the airline pays for the seat or not, who really cares?

There is enough information out there that we can do our own research. I come here because I find out information pretty quickly, I appreicate the manner reviews are written and the photos that come with them. If a product gets a good review, it will never be the sole reason why I buy that product.

I'm not sure where this current "transparency push" came from... but seriously, surely there are more important things to worry about.

Doubleplatinum Banned

Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer Platinum

Member since 07 Feb 2013

Total posts 431

I'm yet to see an overly negative review on a flight where the 'journalist' (term used loosely) was a paid guest of the airline. 

Hi Guest, join in the discussion on Airline reviews

Attach Files