Review: SeatGuru's iPhone app falls short for Aussie travellers

By John Walton, March 22 2012

SeatGuru has finally released an iPhone app to make it easier to choose the best seats -- and avoid the worst ones -- on your next flight.

It's a welcome advance on trying to use the SeatGuru website on your smartphone, and it works in much the same way.

You can search by flight number and date, by route, or by airline:

And you'll get the seat map for your flight:

Tap on a group of seats for information on why they're good (green seats), bad (red) or a little bit of both (yellow).

If you're wondering how well the tapping would translate from the hover-based pop-ups on SeatGuru.com, the answer is 'reasonably well' -- you don't need especially narrow fingers or accurate aim

But the app has some significant flaws, especially for Australian passengers.

For a start, it's out of date. The Virgin Australia section still shows the Virgin Blue logo (which isn't a deal-breaker) and hasn't been updated with Virgin Australia's business class layouts (which definitely is a deal-breaker).

Only two Virgin Australia 737-800 maps are available, one with premium economy (stretching back three rows, so it's not just mis-named business class) and one without:

 

Eagle-eyed frequent flyers will note that Virgin Australia's old premium economy used to go A-C-D-F rather than A-B-C-D too.

The information SeatGuru gives for one of our upcoming Qantas flights also contradicts the seat map on Qantas' website, which shows a different seat configuration.

Here's SeatGuru -- note the lack of row 18 on the right-hand side:

And here's Qantas, which has row 18 on the right:

And don't think that looking up the correct seatmap by the airline's name, like you can on the website, is the quick fix. For some reason, Qantas isn't even listed in the app's master list of airlines.

Plus, on the seat maps we checked, there's neither words nor image showing where the bassinet cribs for babies are located, so that you can avoid them. And some noisy galley kitchens aren't marked either.

Regional Express (REX) isn't included on the airline list either, and with a relatively sizeable fleet of nearly 50 planes, that's an annoying omission for Australians -- especially when some smaller airline are featured.

Another shortcoming is that none of the SeatGuru seating charts are contained in the app itself.

They're all pulled down over your mobile Internet connection, which makes the app entirely useless unless you're connected to the Internet (and painfully slow if you've roamed onto a 2G network overseas).

That isn't very helpful if you're standing in a foreign airport after a delay trying to figure out which seat to pick.

I'll probably keep the SeatGuru app on my iPhone in case I get stuck on an unfamiliar airline and have nothing else to refer to, but we'd suggest starting with our own series of articles explaining how to pick the best seats. In all honesty, SeatGuru is too often inaccurate and inconsistent, so you rely on it at the risk of missing out on the best seats and ending up in one of the worst.

Download the SeatGuru app (it's iPhone-sized, not a native iPad app, so it'll run in the small letterboxed format on your iPad) from the iTunes store: US link | Australia link

John Walton
John Walton

John Walton

Aviation journalist and travel columnist John took his first long-haul flight when he was eight weeks old and hasn't looked back since. Well, except when facing rearwards in business class.

AusFlyer

AusFlyer

10 Mar 2011

Total posts 531

I wonder about the accuracy of Seatguru these days. They haven't even included the new Cathay Pacific Business Class seats which were installed last year... So the information is pretty much out of date. I no longer rely on them since I can't be sure the information is current.

airtraveladdict

airtraveladdict

24 Oct 2011

Total posts 162

I have always used Seatguru to travel but these days they aren't up to date.

On a recent Qantas flight, according to Seatguru, my seat was not an exit row, but I was in an exit row.

I learnt also with Etihad Airways, seatguru did not seatplans for the "new" fleet, which isn't that new, Etihad brought in the airbus in October 2010.

These days I double check with seatexpert as well and another site because seatguru has ALOT of gaps.

colin5353

colin5353

Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer

03 Jul 2011

Total posts 179

Sadly seatexpert doesnt even list Virgin Australia as an airline, either as Virgin Aust or Virgin Blue, when you browse by airline name.  Even more confusing, if you type Virgin in the "airline name" box it appears.  But still doesnt find a flight.

I tried Virgin Aust DJ437 22/6/2012 and nothing was found.

lorks

lorks

08 Apr 2011

Total posts 25

Totally agree: Seatguru became woefully inacurate after it was sold to the online booking agent Expedia and is now just one of it's sales tools. I really hate the way eatguru present seat maps which are inaccurate and where no one from the company has travelled on the aircraft... for example showing bars on aircraft where there are none (check the front of the SQ A380) or seat rows that don’t exist (on the Emirates A380).

I now much prefer the seat maps - which show photographs of every seat - at Airreview. They seem to have been uploaded from the actual airline schematics themselves, so they are dead acurate even down to the window locations, with much more useful information for Aussie flyers.

The Qantas A330 and A380 ones are really good. And just compare its one of the Emirates A380: http://www.airreview.com/Seatmap/Emirates/A380/index.htm and SQ A380: http://www.airreview.com/Seatmap/Singapore/A380/index.htm - knocks socks of Seatguru.



Hi Guest, join in the discussion on Review: SeatGuru's iPhone app falls short for Aussie travellers