Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
Member since 29 Apr 2013
Total posts 20
What do you think..I have enough points for either J class PER-MCR via DBX return, OR...F Class one way and economy return. The J class return makes sense, but I will never get the opportunity to fly F long haul again, so wondering whether it is worth the pain of looking forward on the return leg from the depths of cattle class? Is the difference on EK between J and F worth it?
Member since 17 Aug 2012
Total posts 1,285
If it involves long sectors on the Boeing 777-300ER rather than the Airbus A380, the answer is yes, F is worth it. (They have similar F suites, but the 777 has the old sloping J seat.)
Economy will be miserable anyway, but you're coming home so that's okay.
I say go for it.
Thanks for the response Watson...good info on the seats.
Member since 12 Mar 2014
Total posts 115
It might be nicer to do the F sectors on the return leg - doing them outbound might spoil you forever...
Good point...also they might see my ticket on the outbound sector and see I am coming back F...upgrade to take pity on me? LOL that will be the day !
Member since 09 May 2013
Total posts 46
Y in the 777's is tight. Mightn't be so bad only to Perth but I did SYD-DXB in Y on their 777 and for 14 hours it was way too cramped.
Member since 21 Apr 2012
Total posts 2,059
Oooh I didn't know you could fly to Melchor de Mencos, Guatemala (MCR) via Dubai!
J on both legs cetainly trumps F one-way, Y return.
The service difference between Y and J is enormous. The service difference between J and F, I'm not so sure about...
Do you have access to the Qantas First Class lounges i.e. Are you OW Emerald? If you are, definitely go for J on both legs and try to get seats in the front few rows of the J cabin.
Ignore the last sentence. I failed to read the question accurately and assumed the passenger is flying on QF metal.
Hi Babushka...sorry you are quite correct MAN not MCR...flying on EK and only a Gold member. You are on the same page as my wife who thinks I would be mad to go Y when J is available...just wanted to see what everyone thought of the F/J difference.
Member since 20 Sep 2013
Total posts 316
I would do J on all sectors.TRB is on the money and as he states there are big differences between Y/J.You will be doing youself a favour as First is not worth it.Just enjoy the flights.
Member since 04 Nov 2011
Total posts 197
Yes another vote for J return. F is nice but as stated previously the gap between Y to J is far greater than J to F. The idea of travelling on a 777 in Y on Emirates is torture.
Member since 25 May 2012
Total posts 356
If you can fly F for the PER-DXB & DXB-PER legs and then Y for the DXB-MAN & MAN-DXB legs that'd probably be better.
If you do choose J in both directions, try to select a seat in the forward section on the 777s rather than the main J cabin.
Member since 02 Aug 2012
Total posts 88
My vote is J+J. no question.
British Airways - Executive Club
Member since 24 Jan 2012
Total posts 84
Since the goal is to sample F class, how many miles short are you of redeeming miles for one segment? A MAN-DXB or DXB-PER leg? Is there a cheap mileage run, or some credit card points you can use to push you over?
Member since 29 Jun 2013
Total posts 317
I would go business both ways,to go first one way and economy return would be really painfull and you will always be comparing
Hi Guest, join in the discussion on
Emirates business+business or first+economy?
Already have an ET account? Log in below.
Signing up with Executive Traveller only takes a second and lets you
interact with our community. It's completely free and we'll never pass your information on to
Didn’t receive an activation email? Resend one to yourself here.
If you’ve forgotten your password, simply enter your email address
below, then click 'Submit'. We’ll send you an email to re-activate your account and enter a new password.
If you have not received the activation email, simply enter your email address below, then click 'Submit'. We’ll send you an email containing the activation link.
Subscribe to our free newsletter and get the latest news, reviews, tips and more sent straight to your inbox