Member since 08 Sep 2018
Total posts 2
Hello Fellow Travellers,
Long time reader, first time poster.
As we're all aware the frequency of bad behaviour, ('air rage') in our skies is getting plenty of media coverage and appears to be on the rise. Many of these incidents involve the AFP at our major airports.
I wanted to get a sense from you all about what you think is causing this apparent rise. And also, what constitutes an appropriate use of the AFP in these instances. Last Friday, I saw one such passenger who was two rows forward – I was in a great position to observe and hear. The incident appeared minor and involved a fairly offhand rude hand gesture. It could only be viewed as a personal slight against this crew member. He followed all their instructions, not drunk. No threat was apparent – violence or language. However, on arrival he was frogmarched off – akin to a police state.
For those on here that work in the aviation industry or knowledgable travellers, I wanted to know your thought on whether it is appropriate to engage the AFP in situations of personal offence versus actual or perceived threat.
If so, where would one draw the line –
an eye roll, rude tone, answering back, an offensive gesture?
Member since 24 Apr 2012
Total posts 1,112
Having previously worked on the ground at a major airport, I can share that it's not a case of 'call the AFP every time there's a problem', as such (the police aren't there as babysitters, after all), but if a passenger is displaying certain behavoural signs, becomes aggressive towards staff or others, says something inappropriate relating to travel or aviation security and so on, the AFP are notified as standard procedure, and it's up to them whether to take further action, or whether charges eventuate or just a mere conversation to de-escalate.Of course, there'd be a different procedure if the captain specifically requests AFP attendance on arrival, which is less common but sometimes necessary.
Air New Zealand - Airpoints
Member since 31 Oct 2016
Total posts 204
Situations are far too dynamic to lump them all into one basket.
In the situation you mentioned, it's very possible there's a lot that went on before the situation even caught your attention.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
Member since 28 Oct 2011
Total posts 236
What was the rude hand gesture, and - more importantly - what preceded it?
Well the hand gesture in question was the middle finger. However it wasn’t given with any aggression just an offhand screw you. It should also be noted that despite feeling this way he did follow the crew instructions.
Member since 10 May 2012
Total posts 106
IMHO, there is a culture in Australia of over the top Officialdom from even the most minor people in even the slightest positions of Power, I think it harks back to when you were all criminals off boats and "Authority" was used under the slightest pretext. I've noticed this across many situations. Airline cabin crew are particularly petty in many cases. It's often quite pathetic actually.
Member since 21 Mar 2011
Total posts 428
When it comes to aviation, esp up there in the air, its better to have the ground prepared, ie, have the AFP on hand.
Member since 31 Jan 2016
Total posts 66
No one should have to put up with bad behaviour or bullying, not flying public or airline staff, it makes no difference to me.
I have been on a flight where a person was 'escorted' from the plane by 4 AFP officers before we could depart.
The individual in question allegedly 'struck' their partner while boarding which a staff member saw and was concerned about including 1. safety of other passengers, 2. the safety of the person who was attacked, 3. safety of the flight and 4. their own safety.
While I know there can be minor issues on flights, everyone deserves to make it home safely everyday. Happy to have the AFP...!!!
Delta Air Lines - SkyMiles
Member since 16 Oct 2017
Total posts 165
The real issue here is when freedom of speech should be subservient to larger issues. Hard to disagree it should be so in appropriate circumstances. Impossible to define what is "appropriate" and what isn't. I can only say that, if an encounter is no more serious than someone taking personal offense at the view expressed by another, that should not involve the police. Unless a specific law has been broken e.g. racial slur. And it shouldn't make any difference that the person taking offense is in a position of authority. The usual announcement that pax must obey all directions from the crew is actually misleading. Pax must obey only lawful directions. If two pax are discussing football results and a crew member takes personal offense overhearing criticism of the team they support, can they lawfully direct the pax to stop talking? Certainly not, absent other factors such as disorderly conduct. The same applies to calling the police - the circumstances must objectively justify the reaction.
Member since 24 Apr 2018
Total posts 14
Almost every workplace will evict you for giving the staff a rude hand gesture. Airlines are merely atypical in that they have ready access to law enforcement instead of private security. I don't have a problem with the police at airports being used in this fashion. Don't give the staff rude hand gestures and you will be fine.
Police at airports are funded by the taxpayer and IMHO should not be used as security by private companies (airlines) where no law has been broken, where whatever has happened is a civil matter.
Member since 31 Jul 2018
Total posts 16
Shouldn't need the AFP. Have the Captain eject them from the flight. Add them to the no fly list. Deadbeats like that deserve to catch the bus anyway :)
Member since 17 Sep 2015
Total posts 73
Interesting that the poll is very evenly divided between 'yes', 'no' and 'maybe.'
Hi Guest, join in the discussion on
AFP Engagements on Domestic Flights
Already have an ET account? Log in below.
Signing up with Executive Traveller only takes a second and lets you
interact with our community. It's completely free and we'll never pass your information on to
Didn’t receive an activation email? Resend one to yourself here.
If you’ve forgotten your password, simply enter your email address
below, then click 'Submit'. We’ll send you an email to re-activate your account and enter a new password.
If you have not received the activation email, simply enter your email address below, then click 'Submit'. We’ll send you an email containing the activation link.
Subscribe to our free newsletter and get the latest news, reviews, tips and more sent straight to your inbox