If you check the comments on your review on Emirates more than one poster criticised that you failed to point out the narrow Business seat compared to other carriers flying the same route. So a inflight bar gets raised regardless of aircraft size but seat widths across airlines flying the same ro...

Interesting differences in seat rating between this review and the EK J review - this one four star, the EK one five star. Review seems more willing to find fault on one carrier than another - like faulting for lack of in-flight bar on a much smaller aircraft to an A380.

The article title does make that a bit confusing