Singapore Airlines closes San Francisco airport lounge

By David Flynn, September 30 2017

Singapore Airlines will close its San Francisco SilverKris airport lounge on October 1, 2017 in order to create a massive split-level Polaris business class lounge for Star Alliance partner United Airlines.

United's new Polaris lounge – which will be built in the footprint of the current United Club, just past the airport's security screening zone – will also swallow up the adjacent EVA Air lounge, and is scheduled to open in early 2018.

It will be be one of the largest Polaris lounges in United's network, offering plenty of room for the promised dining areas (above), bar, work booths, daybeds (below) and shower suites.

However, access to that lounge will be restricted to business class and first class travellers on United and Star Alliance partners such as as Singapore Airlines.

Read more: United clarifies Polaris airport lounge access rules

In the meantime, the United Global First Lounge – located further along the terminal, between gates 98 and 100 – will become a temporary United Club.

Frequent flyers travelling in economy or premium economy will make their way to the airport's less-salubrious United Club lounges, one of which will spring up – using the newest United Club concept – in the downstairs space of the current Global First lounge near gate 94.

Singapore Airlines' San Francisco lounge is widely considered to be among the worst in the SilverKris network with cramped and tired seating and a sub-par buffet, so the new Polaris lounge will be a definite upgrade – as long as you're flying at the pointy end of the plane.

David

David Flynn is the Editor-in-Chief of Executive Traveller and a bit of a travel tragic with a weakness for good coffee, shopping and lychee martinis.

Libertyscott

Libertyscott

Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer

19 Aug 2011

Total posts 154

The SQ lounge at SFO is the designated lounge for Air NZ flights to AKL, so it will be interesting to see how NZ provides for its pax (e.g. Elite status) especially during the time when this is closed before the Polaris lounge opens.  

jginpil

jginpil

Virgin Australia - Velocity Rewards

06 Feb 2012

Total posts 31

i am getting really sick of airlines adding a lower tier lounge under their business lounge and fobbing that off to their higher status flyers. 

Grannular

Grannular

31 Mar 2014

Total posts 290

I see no issue. Yes you have status, but you have clearly paid for a lower grade product and that's what you receive.

MRYJDrake

MRYJDrake

Air New Zealand - Airpoints

31 Oct 2016

Total posts 70

If it's that much of a problem.. stop using them..

Rach24

Rach24

30 Jan 2014

Total posts 43

I see where you're coming from but if I'm paying $6000 for a return journey to the west coast I expect to get a seat in the lounge, which often doesn't happen (esp when flying one world out of Sydney) 

jginpil

jginpil

Virgin Australia - Velocity Rewards

06 Feb 2012

Total posts 31

I agree but if thats the case make the policy uniform. the whole selling point is that you get asscess to the business lounge. if they say you get access to our network of offcut lounges then at least you know what level you are playing on but the degrading of bennifits that are supposeed to be part of a stats level by changing clasifications annoys me. having said that when i am in business i prefer to have the rif raf in a seperate section too. i would just like them to call a lounge a lounge.

Steve987

Steve987

23 Feb 2015

Total posts 255

It is an interesting approach and both makes sense while appearing short sighted in that frequent flyers are a far greater cash cow than the once a year first or business flyer and anything that disenfranchises them is a risky move.

I think Qantas gets it about right. Same physical space but differentiated experience re chauffeur service and spa access.

Newbie7

Newbie7

Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer

04 Dec 2012

Total posts 38

I don't know, I feel most frequent international flyers out of the States would either be purchasing into F/J to begin with or be flying Y so frequently that they have international upgrades at hand. Let's say the semi-frequent international flyer (maybe 6 times a year, once every two months) in Y is the one that gets shafted, and s/he pays an average of $1,000 for the Y class ticket. That means to break even with a once-a-year F/J customer, they have to be paying around $6,000. J class tickets often go for $5,000, so I think saying that (semi) frequent int'l Y travelers being far greater cash cows may not be entirely accurate. Also, those that are cash cows solely flying Y get invited into Global Services and whatnot, and I'm sure they will still get special treatment on the down-low. If anything, I think UA is hoping that these kinds of distinctions will elevate their premium experience enough to gain back premium traffic they've lost to their competition over the years.

This all said, I do agree with what you said about QF getting it right - and as a semi-frequent int'l traveler myself, I love those benefits!

henrus

henrus

Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer

23 Oct 2013

Total posts 714

Maybe (I may be dreaming here), Qantas might opt to use the new larger lounge instead of the AF thing they currently serve up.

David

David

24 Oct 2010

Total posts 2337

I severely doubt Qantas would use a United lounge... my hopes are that we'll one day see an LAX-style Oneworld lounge at SFO.

Packetman21

Packetman21

Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer

28 Jul 2016

Total posts 108

I hope so, that would be awesome

Nouflyer

Nouflyer

Air New Zealand - Airpoints

05 Nov 2014

Total posts 14

The Singapore Airlines lounge is as bad as a United Club.

I use the AMEX Centurion Lounge instead, a short airside stroll back into the domestic terminal, and it is terrific.

cbourl

cbourl

United Airlines - Mileage Plus

12 Sep 2011

Total posts 110

Join the discussion Love Polaris Did it EWR-SFO 3 weeks ago - best seat 1A Always 1a for me in F and C Shame its not available to Australia Beats crappy Continental BusinessFirst on the Dreamliner (What a waste of a great aircraft) Im 6ft3 so Polaris was a treat -what is called Polaris to/from Australia on the 787-9 is shocking and as bad as Lufthansa Business Class LongHaul United have much better crew than LH of course, except in Lufthansa First which is exoteric

Hi Guest, join in the discussion on Singapore Airlines closes San Francisco airport lounge