Qantas hits pause on planned non-stop flights to Paris
By Chris Chamberlin, June 3 2019
Qantas’ plans to expand non-stop flights from Perth to Europe are on hold, with the airline’s ongoing disputes with Perth Airport causing the carrier to shelve plans to go beyond the current Perth-London service out of Australia’s west coast.
The two companies are currently in disagreement over both airport usage charges, and which international terminal Qantas can use in Perth for its expanding network of international flights – a stoush that already cost the city a non-stop Qantas flight from Perth to Johannesburg.
In a briefing with media at the International Air Transport Association (IATA) Annual General Meeting in Seoul, Qantas Group CEO Alan Joyce shared that “today, we would be in the process of preparing for further services out of Perth into Europe – we would be ordering aircraft to do Perth to Paris, which would be the next one on our list, except for the fact that there’s a dispute with Perth Airport.”
Referring to the battle over airport charges, in which Perth Airport is suing Qantas in the courts of Western Australia, Joyce continues: “Until that’s resolved, we’re not going to reward bad behaviour. We don’t think that’s the right thing to do with our business, so unfortunately, we’re not expanding (out of Perth) at the moment.”
Speaking to the broader issues with management at Perth Airport and Qantas’ planned Perth-Johannesburg route that didn’t take off, Joyce says that “basically I’ve never heard of an airport stopping an airline doing a new route, so they’re doing unbelievable things that they need to get resolved.”
Executive Traveller understands that Qantas was hoping to use its newly-designed Terminal 3/4 precinct in Perth – where flights to London already depart – to host the airline’s other international services including Johannesburg, but that Perth Airport was insisting that these flights depart from the other side of the airport.
Qantas is said to have found this impractical, given the geography of Perth Airport and the need to swing aircraft between domestic and international flights: a difficult feat when it takes the better part of an hour to tow planes from one side of the airport to the other, not to mention the cumbersome transfer experience for passengers making that inter-terminal journey.
Still, Joyce is optimistic. “I hope it doesn’t go on until 2022-23” when Project Sunrise is due to kick off, and the potential of non-stop flights to Paris from Australia’s east coast exists, “so we think it would be resolved before then.”
“We’ll be very excited about doing Perth-Paris as the next cab off the rank," provided those disputes are resolved.
Approached by Executive Traveller for comment, a spokesperson for Perth Airport said the airport "has repeatedly stated it is ready to host a Qantas Johannesburg service through T1 International where 17 other international carriers operate.
"Perth Airport has secured pricing agreements with 23 out of 24 airlines which operate at the airport – which is evidence that our approach to pricing is both fair and reasonable. Perth Airport is seeking a speedy resolution to the Qantas non-payment of airport charges issue and the current independent arbitration through the Supreme Court will best enable this."
On the delivery flight of Qantas’ first Boeing 787-9 in October 2017, Joyce told Executive Traveller (formerly Australian Business Traveller) that the airline had already pencilled in a daily schedule for the planned Perth-Paris flights.
"For the first time we have daily rights for Paris. Last time we were in Paris we only could do three days a week, which made it sub-economical and meant that we weren’t attracting the business market, but now that has changed."
Joyce also had his eye on a non-stop flight into Germany, with Frankfurt – which the airline previously flew via Singapore before axing the route in 2013 – sitting on the shortlist.
"Germany is still a big market and it's been hard for us in the past when we were flying through a hub, so the opportunity there is actually quite real.” However, that route is also likely to be collateral damage in Qantas’ stoush with Perth Airport.
Chris Chamberlin is attending the IATA AGM in Seoul as a guest of IATA.
Chris Chamberlin is the Associate Editor of Executive Traveller, and lives by the motto that a journey of a thousand miles begins not just with a single step, but also a strong latte, a theatre ticket, and later in the day, a good gin and tonic.
27 Apr 2017
Total posts 39
'we would be ordering aircraft to do Perth to Paris'.
Sounds like a convenient excuse. An airline doesn't change their orders for aircraft, which have multi-year lead-in times, as a result of a dispute with a single airport operator.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
02 Sep 2018
Total posts 146
This would likely involve activating one of the options to increase an existing aircraft order and not entirely new orders.
27 Apr 2017
Total posts 39
So say Qantas declines to take up its options to increase an aircraft order. 6 months later, Perth Airport changes its mind. Qantas has now lost its spot in the order queue at Boeing and is now left high and dry without any aircraft to undertake a route. Doesn't sound likely, does it?
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
06 Oct 2016
Total posts 115
You buy your way in and out of the cue (value can go either way, it isn't always cash), when you sell your spot to another party you usually negotiate conditions to back out, again that works both ways
17 Sep 2015
Total posts 391
Agree. More likely that QF found that market research indicated it couldn't fill its planes at an acceptable yield per seat.
It used to operate (using its own metal) several flights a day to Europe (including UK). Now it's down to just a daily A380 and a daily B789 via (respectively) SIN and PER.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
05 Oct 2016
Total posts 62
WTH is PER playing at...Who cares what terminal they use????? Of course 17 other airlines use the international terminal. They don't have domestic flights in coming on their own airline... PER airport just get on with life.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
03 May 2013
Total posts 21
No, they don't change their aircraft ordering, but they do deploy those aircraft onto alternative routes. The 787 that might have been used Perth to Paris might now be used on the new Brisbane to Chicago route.
Jetstar Airways - Qantas Frequent Flyer
24 Aug 2018
Total posts 76
The current stop- over in Perth on the Melbourne to LHR route is a brilliant, but sparsely used lounge. Food offerings, include BBQ ‘ed goods, great barista coffee, plenty of non and alcoholic drinks and ample shower facilities. It would appear a shame not to have access to it on the proposed Melbourne to Paris route
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
15 Aug 2017
Total posts 109
Has their ever been a airport that stands in the way of new flights!? Perth Airport absolute disgrace and as for the Labor WA government. Tourism minister Paul Papalia / Premier Mark McGowan how about stepping in and helping with something that is STOPPING additional tourists and flights? Nothing but silence from them on this whole matter.
American Airlines - AAdvantage
13 Jul 2015
Total posts 249
I think for those of us in Melbourne/Sydney, most would still prefer to go via Singapore/Middle East to get to Europe as there are more route options than Perth to London (and they're slightly quicker), so it's not really a big loss, but more routes are always helpful!
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
23 Sep 2017
Total posts 147
For all the hoopla about non-stop flights from Australia to UK/Europe, having to transit Perth does not a non-stop journey make, at least from the East coast. Nice place Perth, but hardly a remarkable stopover option for outbound Oz pax. SIN any time. All that aside, this PER airport impasse is a disgrace.
Virgin Australia - Velocity Rewards
20 Nov 2017
Total posts 104
Plus, for the PER option, you are forced to fly the Qantas Nightmareliner.
08 Aug 2017
Total posts 44
Have you flown it? The J class hard and soft product is terrific. Can’t speak for Y.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
07 Feb 2015
Total posts 149
Chris did you approach Perth Airport for comments? I wonder what their side of they story is. This dispute has been going on for some time now and it's not really doing any good PR-wise to either the airport or Qantas.
27 Apr 2017
Total posts 39
Exactly. There's always two sides to every story. Yet AusBT only reports one.
24 Oct 2010
Total posts 2431
As has been mentioned, we have approached Perth Airport's media team for a response. When we get a reply we'll update the article accordingly.
American Airlines - AAdvantage
02 Jun 2019
Total posts 13
The authorities in Perth are crazy for not letting Qantas do a Perth to Paris flight. Who cares what terminal the flights departs from. You can't say to Qantas, spend millions on a new lounge a facilities for a London flight knowing they want Paris and Johannesburg and then tell them to use the regular international terminal. I thought Western Australia was pro Qantas country.
Virgin Australia - Velocity Rewards
20 Nov 2017
Total posts 104
The airport is happy for QF to do Perth to Paris, it is just that QF is not paying airport fees due and payable, unlike 23 of the 24 airlines which use PER. More spin from Qantas, it's sickening.
06 Jan 2015
Total posts 69
Actually the state government made a huge contribution to build the required immigration facilies and lounge facility for Qantas to ensure the London flights went ahead.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
09 Sep 2013
Total posts 177
Agree - around $20m from memory to satisfy Mr Joyce.
03 Jul 2017
Total posts 7
Qantas are acting like little kids in this dispute. The ASA negotiation was offered at a lower rate to the previous 7 years. All airlines agreed except for Qantas who decided to pay 40% less that the invoiced amount until they got more of a discount. Using this as an excuse not to commit to new routes is pretty pathetic.
10 Jun 2017
Total posts 7
Oh of course. But wait, Virgin Australia operate from T1, so passengers can connect straight through Internationally from Domestic flights, because it is the same terminal. Qantas has to move passengers from T3/4 to the other side of the airport, which means connectivity issues. . So VA have a competitive advantage, while Qantas is trying to make new routes into Europe and bring pax into Aust. But no, it's Qantas that are acting like little kids, right? Perth Airport is an outdated disgrace that its management should be ashamed of.
12 Feb 2014
Total posts 230
Qantas has a point if PER insists on all international flights departing from the other side of the airport. Co-locating the domestic and international flights is the whole point of making PER a hub for European flights. Otherwise you just have another SYD on your hands. Until a new domestic terminal is built in the international precinct, as Virgin have, then Qantas should stick to its stance.
24 Apr 2017
Total posts 64
Are they allowed to use Sydney domestic terminals for their international flights?
They need to follw the rules/law and use the international terminals with all the proper facilities including federal customs/immigration/baggage screening processes.
10 Jun 2017
Total posts 7
But it is ok for Virgin to operate wholly from T1, assuring seamless connections for International Passengers, but Qantas has to move all its domestic passenger to the other side of the airport while trying to build a market fro direct access to Europe? P1, you have no idea what you are talking about.
07 Mar 2017
Total posts 45
As above, that's the Qantas side. Should hear the Perth airport side as well for balance.
24 Oct 2010
Total posts 2431
Just to advise that we have approached Perth Airport for its comment and will update the story on their response.
17 Sep 2015
Total posts 391
'The West Australian' had an article on 30 March 2019 that gave Perth Airport's side of the story.
Why not report what it previously said?
This would give the ABT story more balance. Not really fair to only report QF's side of the story given that it allegedly owes Perth Airport millions in unpaid fees.
24 Oct 2010
Total posts 2431
We'd rather approach Perth Airport directly, we have done that and the article has now been updated with comments by a Perth Airport spokesperson.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
08 Dec 2011
Total posts 30
Didn't realise it was a public holiday in WA today did you?
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
29 Nov 2013
Total posts 481
It's been a public holiday in Perth for about 6 years now...
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
08 Dec 2011
Total posts 30
Is that meant to be funny?
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
16 Nov 2016
Total posts 26
Someone is surely short-sighted - a generous WA government subsidy to Qantas should be in-force for the airlines to open more international routes. Yet, someone is still barguing about airport fees?! How did this happen?
17 Sep 2015
Total posts 391
Why should governments subsidise international air travel? There's plenty better uses for taxes. This would only distort the market.
Virgin Australia - Velocity Rewards
20 Nov 2017
Total posts 104
Yes, exactly, Traveller14. I'm pretty sure that hard-working shop assistants and tradies would not be happy that their taxes are being used to pump up Alan Joyce's bonus.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
16 Nov 2016
Total posts 26
Because more domestic and international travelers going to or transiting through Perth will help boosting the local economy, lifting the domestic buying power, securing more jobs across the industry chains, putting Perth on the world map, potentially lowering airfares connecting European destinations and ultimately strengthening GDP. Subsiding international routes will help the market - especially in the long term, rather than distorting it - it comes with its disadvantages (I agree to a limited extent), but won't outweigh the multifaceted advantages. Also, not a cent from the subsidy will go to Alan Joyce's bonus @stmaus
04 Jun 2018
Total posts 20
This battle is so frustrating considering the state government funded T3 refurbishment / international conversion has 3 gates and was clearly designed for a lot more traffic than just 2 daily flights, yet PAPL refuses to budge with negotiating with Qantas and allowing them to operate more flights out of said purpose built terminal. At this stage it is 100% an issue over the airport charges as Qantas ceded control of T4 to PAPL this year, so there is no longer any valid argument in relation to Qantas managed tenants benefiting from the services over PAPL managed tenants.
15 Feb 2018
Total posts 46
I am amazed that sympathy is with Perth Airport. If you had a business that could utilise PER to CDG, or PER to FRA, or any other airport, I am sure you wouldn’t be sympathising with Perth Airport.
24 Oct 2010
Total posts 2431
This article has now been updated with comments from a Perth Airport spokesperson.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
08 Dec 2011
Total posts 30
Quote from Perth Airport appears to be a rehashed statement from previous stories about Jo-burg flight and not in response to specifics of this article or Joyce's comments in Seoul.
24 Oct 2010
Total posts 2431
It’s the quote they gave us - not unusual for PRs to have a fixed and approved line in response to an issue.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
15 Aug 2017
Total posts 109
Thanks ausbt for the Perth airport update. Regardless of the financial dispute which is a seperate matter I ask to this:
Qantas
19 Apr 2012
Total posts 1123
Perth Airport didn’t say how many of those other airlines have t tow a plane across a field for its own international connection. The answer of course is none. This is a ridiculous request unless Perth Airport wants more A330s or 787s based in Perth which ain’t gonna happen.
15 Jun 2018
Total posts 4
No one has noticed that this media release was timed for the 'Western Australia' Day public holiday marking then founding WA.
24 Apr 2012
Total posts 3056
Hi daveX, just some background information on the timing: the IATA AGM is a three-day event, running this year from June 1-3 (that's Saturday to today, Monday), so as with all the airlines, the choice on timing for media briefings is quite limited during the event, as the schedule is quite packed for airline execs and media alike. (As it was, today's briefing was only possible by scheduling a sit-down practically at the crack of dawn, before the conference events began.)
08 Feb 2018
Total posts 104
The response from Perth Airport totally avoids the issue at hand. The WA taxpayer has contributed millions towards the terminal improvements, and now the airport is not allowing the terminal to be used for its intended purpose. Surely this is misappropriation of public funds and the government must get involved.
15 Jun 2018
Total posts 4
I don't think it's tenable to suggest that a 'national' airline drops one of its own country's largest and economically significant cities.. let alone abandoning 1/3 of the entire country in the process.
31 Jul 2012
Total posts 21
How do you figure this affects 1/3rd of the population of the country?
24 Jun 2017
Total posts 5
Perth Airport should not be bending over backwards to help out an airline that has not paid it's invoices in full. Surely business people on this forum agree, you pay your bills, if you want favours coming your way!
17 May 2012
Total posts 81
This is the same airport that shortly after Alan became CEO was provided NO international flights out of Perth by Qantas
24 Apr 2017
Total posts 64
Time for Perth Airport to hike up rates for International flights leaving from the Domestic terminal to AT LEAST double what the charges are for using the proper Domestic terminal.
16 Dec 2016
Total posts 45
To those who think this is a convenient excuse for Qantas you are crazy. The Per-LHR route is profitable and has incredibly high customer satisfaction. It provides a once stop option to a large number of Australian ports (including many in Regional WA Perth Airport!) and the value to the local economy is way above predictions with an average of 5 nights for those that stopover in Perth. Perth Airport is a monopoly if you read the productivity commission report you can see all of us are being gouged. What other country’s airports fight against their national carrier?!? I love WA but I’m not visiting until Perth Airport wake up.
QFF
03 Sep 2014
Total posts 12
the owners of Perth Airport have been dragging the feet for years on improvements as they continue to gouge airlines and passengers on exhorbitant fees. They were forced to do something about the 50 year old terminal before it fell down. As for the 3rd runway, it is at least 3 years away as they have allowed businesses to lease the land where it goes, and have to give 3 years notice to end the leases.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
16 Sep 2011
Total posts 14
Before Qantas axed 100% of their international services from Perth they were quite happy to operate out of the international terminal. When they reintroduced services to Singapore they were happy to do the same. When they started seasonal flights to Auckland they were from the international terminal. It was only once they were lobbying for the PER-LHR service that they suddenly all had to be in the same precinct, the woefully out dated and inaccessible terminal 3/4. Then suddenly the world would end if they had to move. Step in the WA Government with tens of millions in funding for a second international terminal in Perth. Qantas are greedy, nothing more.
15 Mar 2018
Total posts 39
16 Dec 2016
Total posts 45
Oh come on OzJames - Perth Airport is a monopoly and has none of the competitive pressure that Qantas does. Australian aviation is the most deregulated in the world yet the airports operate without competition. Sure it is a business but it can charge whatever it likes and we don’t have a choice. Just have a look at their charges and you’ll appreciate we are all being ripped off and they are operating against the interest of Perth and Western Australians. If Perth doesn’t make the most of this opportunity and create a hub market then once non stop flights happen from the East Coast no one will bother trying this again.
17 Sep 2015
Total posts 391
I'm sure Perth Airport's charges are high and consumers are being ripped off through higher than necessary charges, but deregulated or not, passengers only have a "choice" of two airline groups that in recent months have reduced capacity on many major routes and ceased any pretext of a 'fare war.'
Virgin Australia - Velocity Rewards
20 Nov 2017
Total posts 104
AirAsia offers $99 flights from Perth, so it's not PAPL's charges that are the problem.
16 Dec 2016
Total posts 45
Traveller14 how many domestic airlines do you think this country can support? So you think opening domestic travel to international operators would help local travellers? You have no idea what you are talking about.
10 Dec 2018
Total posts 40
Why not via DRW? Quicker/shorter to LHR, CDG and most West Europe major destinations (exceptions FCO and ATH). Looking at ExpertFlyer seat plans there is, as one would expect, some pickup at PER, but probably not a deal-breaker.
17 Sep 2015
Total posts 391
Since I won't be using QF, or QF9/10, I can be neutral on this. My impression was that quite a good eprcentage - perhaps in excess of 55 per cent - boarded in PER for QF9, or alighted from QF10.
20 Feb 2012
Total posts 65
Completely agree. I always felt they should go via DRW. Can also collect BNE pax, it’s on Australian soil and has tourism potential for inbound.
Qantas - Qantas Frequent Flyer
11 Oct 2014
Total posts 551
The perfect solution and time for QF to move all their proposed and operating Europe flights from PER to Broome (BME) ! LOL
Benefits galore:
Hi Guest, join in the discussion on Qantas hits pause on planned non-stop flights to Paris